But the big question remains: do carbon offsets actually work? And should they be automatically included in the purchase of an airline ticket?

Let’s dive in.

What Are Carbon Offsets?

Carbon offsets are investments in environmental projects, such as reforestation or renewable energy, that are designed to compensate for the carbon emissions produced by an individual or organization. For example, if you take a flight that emits one ton of CO₂, you might pay to support a project that removes an equivalent amount of CO₂ from the atmosphere.

Where Carbon Offsets Work

1. Cookstove Projects in Rural Africa

In many parts of sub-Saharan Africa, households rely on traditional open fires for cooking, which release large amounts of CO₂ and harmful indoor air pollutants. Projects like the Clean Cookstoves Initiative provide efficient stoves that significantly reduce fuel consumption and carbon emissions. According to the Gold Standard, a leading carbon offset certification body, these projects can cut emissions by up to 70% per household.

Not only do these offsets reduce carbon, but they also improve health and save time for local communities—proving that carbon offsetting can have real, multifaceted benefits when well-designed and monitored.

2. Reforestation Projects in Panama

The Darien Reforestation Project in Panama, certified by Verra’s Verified Carbon Standard (VCS), focuses on restoring degraded pastureland with native tree species. This helps sequester carbon over decades, protects biodiversity, and supports sustainable livelihoods for local farmers.

Because it's independently verified and provides ongoing data on carbon capture, it’s considered a solid example of how carbon offsets can make a measurable impact.

Where It Doesn't Work

3. Questionable Forest Preservation Projects

Not all forest-based offsets are created equal. A 2023 investigation by The Guardian and Die Zeit found that over 90% of the rainforest carbon offsets approved by Verra (then the world’s leading certifier) were largely ineffective. Many projects claimed to prevent deforestation that likely would not have happened anyway—known as “non-additionality.”

In these cases, buyers paid for "protection" of forests that were never under threat, which means no additional carbon was actually saved. This highlights the critical need for transparency, third-party verification, and long-term monitoring.

Do Carbon Offsets in the Airline Industry Really Work?

Air travel is responsible for roughly 2.5% of global CO₂ emissions, and that number is expected to grow. In response, many airlines now offer carbon offset programs, giving passengers the option to "neutralize" their flight emissions. Some even bundle offsets into ticket prices or promote them during checkout.

But the effectiveness of these programs is mixed.

Why It Might Work:

  • If the airline partners with reputable, third-party verified projects (like those under Gold Standard or VCS), the offsets can indeed compensate for flight-related emissions.
  • It creates awareness and can inspire travelers to consider the environmental impact of their journeys.

Why It Might Not:

  • Voluntary offsets can give a false sense of “guilt-free” travel, discouraging systemic changes like investing in cleaner aircraft or reducing unnecessary flights.
  • Poorly vetted offsets, especially those tied to unreliable forest preservation or outdated technology, often don't deliver the promised reductions.
  • Most offset programs don’t account for non-CO₂ emissions from flights (like nitrogen oxides or contrail cirrus), which can double the climate impact of flying.

Should Carbon Offsets Be Included with Every Airline Ticket?

There’s a growing debate about whether offsets should be optional or mandatory. Including them automatically could increase participation and ensure more funds go to verified environmental projects. However, it also risks greenwashing if airlines use low-quality or misleading offsets just to check a box.

Instead, some experts argue for a hybrid approach:

  • Offer opt-in carbon offsets that are clearly explained, transparently sourced, and independently verified.
  • Invest in long-term solutions like sustainable aviation fuel (SAF), electric planes, and more efficient routes.

Ultimately, offsets are a temporary bridge—not a permanent fix. But when used responsibly, they can be one piece of a broader strategy to reduce aviation’s environmental footprint.

The Bottom Line

Carbon offsets can work—if they are:

  • Additional (they wouldn’t happen without your contribution)
  • Verified by credible third parties
  • Transparent and long-term

When it comes to flying, offsets shouldn’t be seen as a free pass, but rather a way to take some responsibility for emissions while we transition to cleaner travel technologies. 

So next time you fly, ask yourself: Where is this carbon offset going? Is it making a real difference? And should we be doing more than just ticking a box? Here too, mass adoption, political will to stimulate mass adoption and a low price for sustainability are key. 

If you would like to see an atricle on a particular topic related to sustainability and travel?, Drop us a line at explore@ginandtonictravel.com

Article by Marc Geuzinge, Co Founder and Travel Specialist at Gin & Tonic Travel

All rights reserved. You are welcome to share this material from this page, but it may not be copied, re-published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed

Sources:

Want to travel smarter and greener? Be informed, ask questions, and make your travel choices count.